News » Family

Va. Gym to Allow Gay Parents to Join After Lawsuit

Friday Jul 6, 2012

ROANOKE, Va. (AP) - A Roanoke fitness club has changed its membership policies after a gay man sued, claiming it sold him a family membership, then revoked it after realizing that his family consisted of two fathers and a son.

Carilion Clinic, the parent company of Roanoke Athletic Club, said Thursday on its Facebook page that it will offer household memberships to cohabiting couples and their dependent children under age 22 who live with them.

The change at Roanoke Athletic Club and Botetourt Athletic Club is taking place "in recognition of the many contemporary households that can benefit from our facilities," according to the posting. What had been called a "family membership" is now called a "household membership."

William Trinkle, of Roanoke, sued Roanoke Athletic Club and Carilion last week in Roanoke Circuit Court, alleging breach of contract and violation of the Virginia Consumer Protection Act. Trinkle said that he; his partner, Juan Granados; and their two-year-old son, Oliver, were barred from using the facilities because they didn't meet club officials' definition of a family. He sought to have the club honor the contract and reinstate his family membership.

Trinkle's lawyer, John Fishwick Jr., said his client is pleased with the change, which he said will benefit many types of families. Fishwick said he was discussing the status of the lawsuit with Trinkle in light of the policy change, and said he hasn't communicated directly with Carilion Clinic officials.

An email and a telephone message left for Carilion Clinic spokesman Eric Earnhart weren't returned by Thursday afternoon.

Trinkle purchased a family membership May 15. Club officials approved Trinkle's application, and the family started using the facilities. Trinkle and Granados were shocked when the club's operations director told them in a telephone call May 24 that same-sex couples don't meet what they said was Virginia's legal definition of family.

"It came out of left field, and it was a punch to the gut to both of us," Trinkle said earlier Thursday in a telephone interview. "We joined the pool so we could have swimming lessons and enjoy the summer by the pool, simple as that."

Virginia doesn't recognize same-sex marriage but state law doesn't specifically define what constitutes a family.

Copyright Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


  • Bob K, 2012-07-06 17:15:15

    YEAH, like now I would take my little kid there, to be exposed to "There go those queers who degraded the Family membership into a Household membership" --- Will ought to go there only to "Trinkle" in their pool, then head out to someplace where his family is truly welcome, in my view.

  • IndianaJag, 2012-07-07 10:56:50

    Nice, and that’s how you would change the world - by acting like the haters.

  • Oh Jed said:, 2012-07-07 18:25:59

    Well, at least he didn’t suggest them taking a dump in the pool.

  • Bob K, 2012-07-07 19:32:41

    @IndianaJag -- so you would have them attend the club as if nothing happened and pretend their child would not be subjected to scorn? Your homophobia makes you pick at my ironical little suggestion and gloss over the main one.

  • Oh Jed said:, 2012-07-08 11:15:48

    I think private "clubs" are stupid to begin with unless you’re 6 and they include Spanky and Buckwheat. Get over yourself already. I was adding levity to an intense, comment. The End.

Add New Comment

Comments on Facebook