Entertainment » Movies


by Kyle Thomas Smith
EDGE Media Network Contributor
Saturday Jun 9, 2012

Celine Sciamma's "Tomboy" takes a sensitive, non-agenda-pushing look at young Laure's (Zoe Harens) life as "Mikael," the new kid in a French suburb, where boys are romping through woods and fields, enjoying their last days of freedom before the new school year. A pretty ten-year-old named Lisa (Jeanne Disson)--the only girl in the pack--encounters Laure, assumes she's a boy and asks "his" name. Laure plays along, saying her name is Mikael. As the summer progresses, Lisa develops a crush on "Mikael," who not only can roughhouse with the best of them, but also has no problem fitting in with the boys on every level, even if she has to put a little clay bulge in her bathing suit when they go swimming. Not long after Lisa and "Mikael" share an innocuous first kiss, Laure's secret gets blown wide open after moms get called in to address a fight that Laure/Mikael has had with another boy.

But was Laure lying about being a boy or is she a boy at heart? Or is she just a tomboy who'll grow out of it? Or should she grow out of it at all?

Celine Sciamma’s "Tomboy" takes a sensitive, non-agenda-pushing look at young Laure’s (Zoe Harens) life as "Mikael."

One of the many refreshing things about Sciamma's film is that it leaves all these questions open while presenting scenarios in a most patient and even-handed way. "Tomboy" employs the subtle technique of other great contemporary French films, like Olivier Assayas' "L'Heure d'été," where a slow camera slides across simple scenes that contain sparse dialogue, expanding the audience's capacity for contemplation. Rather than being rattled by the child's gender dysphoria like the family and town in Alain Berliner's "Ma Vie en Rose," Laure's family is loving and kind, the neighborhood kids seem alright, and we leave with the sense that she'll be able to negotiate identity questions without suffering Brandon Teena's fate.

89 mins.

Kyle Thomas Smith is author of the novel 85A (Bascom Hill, 2010). He lives in Brooklyn with his husband and two cats.


  • , 2012-06-10 11:59:00

    Did you really misspell Brandon Teena’s famous name? Does anyone edit article’s pertaining to Transgender issues or is it just that the cis-privileged people who write these articles just could not care less about trans* people. Also putting quotation marks around gender pronouns that don’t match the gender assigned to this child at birth are insulting to this character’s gender presentation and clearly show the lack of respect this author has for trans* people’s lived identities . Yes the questions of identity are left open, and yes this child may not indeed be trans* however, the level of cross-gender identification displayed by the character warrant respect regardless because when people are denied their identities it sets them up for a life of misery.

Add New Comment

Comments on Facebook